The Law of Surprise in The Witcher: A Perplexing Concept

In Andrzej Sapkowski's The Witcher series, the Law of Surprise emerges as a complex and mysterious law that has puzzled many readers. This law plays a significant role in the series, particularly when it comes to the destiny of children who, under certain circumstances, are given to witchers. However, the outcomes of the Law of Surprise have not always been aligned with the expectations of the recipients, often leading to discussions about fate and destiny.

Historical Context and Examples of the Law of Surprise

The Law of Surprise is introduced in the book The Last Wish, detailing its origin and how it has been applied throughout history. According to the narrative, this law is one of the oldest and most respected among human beliefs. While the law is typically invoked for the benefit of a witcher, who receives a child as part of a promise, statistics seem to defy the norm. An intriguing aspect of the Law of Surprise is that in every case documented, the child has been a boy, until the arrival of Ciri. This pattern has led many to question the true nature and reliability of the law.

Notable Examples of the Law of Surprise

Heroic Dwarf: A kid given to dwarves through this law grew up to be a great hero, showcasing the potential for a child under this law to achieve great feats. Mad De: A cursed person named Mad De received a child named Supree through the Law of Surprise, who eventually lifted the curse that was upon him, demonstrating the transformative power of the law. Queen Zivelina: The queen of Metinna received a child surprise through the influence of the gnome Rumplestelt, which helped her secure the throne, highlighting the political and social contexts of the law. Cirilla (Ciri): The most significant example is the story of Cirilla, also known as Ciri, who is the daughter of Pavetta and Urcheon, a legendary witcher. Interestingly, Ciri was not born as a result of the Law of Surprise but is still integral to the narrative, representing a departure from the established pattern.

Geralt's Perspective on the Law of Surprise

From Geralt's perspective, the Law of Surprise is filled with ambiguity and skepticism. In The Last Wish, Geralt notes that children conceived through this law are far more likely to be unexpected items such as old boots than actual children. This skepticism is further emphasized during a conversation with Calanthé, where Geralt expresses his doubt about the Law of Surprise and its predictive power. He believes that the stories of previous Law of Surprise users are merely legends, and he holds a cautious attitude due to his holistic and skeptical nature. However, as he encounters Ciri, his perspective begins to change.

The second incidence of the Law of Surprise with Ciri proves too difficult for Geralt to ignore, leading him to reassess his views on fate and destiny. His skepticism remains, but his deep emotional connection to Ciri makes it impossible for him to let her go, even when circumstances force him to intervene. His journey with Ciri thus becomes a testament to the unpredictability and power of the Law of Surprise.

Conclusion

The Law of Surprise in The Witcher series is a fascinating concept that challenges the boundaries of traditional storytelling and human belief. It not only shapes the destinies of characters but also invites readers to question the nature of fate and destiny. The recurring themes of the Law of Surprise, particularly in the story of Ciri, make it an enduring and intriguing element in the series, continuing to captivate listeners and readers alike.