The Unethical and Ineffective Practice of Canine Discipline: Why Hitting with Rolled-Up Newspapers is Outdated

Some individuals, often unknowingly, perpetuate an outdated and inhumane form of discipline by hitting their dogs with rolled-up newspapers on their rumps. This method, rooted in 1950s and earlier training theories, is not only unethical but also ineffective. We will explore the rationale behind this practice, its effects on dogs, and the reasons why animal behaviorists and trainers strongly discourage it in favor of modern, positive reinforcement methods.

Understanding the Rationale of the Outdated Practice

People who use hitting as a disciplining method often cite two main reasons:

Immediate Feedback

The rationale behind this approach is to provide immediate feedback to the dog whenever it exhibits undesirable behavior. The owner believes that a light tap can serve as a negative consequence, associating the action with the undesirable behavior. This is similar to how a parent might use a gentle swat to correct a child's behavior.

Physical Correction

Some owners think that physical contact can serve as a deterrent against certain behaviors. They believe that a tap can teach the dog that a particular behavior is not acceptable without the need for more formal training or positive reinforcement.

Modern Dog Training and Its Advantages

However, it is crucial to note that these methods are generally discouraged by modern animal behaviorists and trainers for a number of reasons. Positive reinforcement techniques, which focus on rewarding desired behaviors, are proven to be far more effective. These techniques help to build a positive relationship between the dog and its owner and are more humane.

Positive Reinforcement

Positive reinforcement involves rewarding the dog for good behavior. This can be done through treats, praise, or play. These rewards reinforce the good behavior and strengthen the association in the dog's mind. By using positive reinforcement, you can shape the dog's behavior without resorting to punishment.

The Dangers of Using Physical Punishment

While some people might see hitting the dog with a rolled-up newspaper as a harmless deterrent, it can actually cause physical harm and instill fear in the animal. This can lead to a number of issues:

Fear and Anxiety

Dogs are highly intelligent and sensitive creatures. Even a light tap can cause fear and anxiety, making the dog avoid the owner or the environment where it received the punishment.

Agression

When a dog feels fear or anxiety due to physical punishment, it may act out in a more aggressive manner. This can create a dangerous situation for both the dog and the owner.

Reduced Bonding

The bond between a dog and its owner is crucial. Any form of physical punishment can damage this bond, leading to a strained relationship and decreased trust.

Conclusion and Recommendations

The use of hitting with a rolled-up newspaper is not only outdated but also detrimental to the physical and emotional well-being of the dog. Modern approaches to dog training, such as positive reinforcement, are more effective and humane.

Explore my Quora Profile for insights on humane and effective dog training methods that can strengthen the bond between a dog and its owner while ensuring the animal's well-being.