The Ultimate Guide to NYC Take-Out Pizza: From Bleeker to Brooklyn

When it comes to pizza, the best is often the one that's still fresh out of the oven. However, for many pizza lovers, the convenience of take-out can't be beaten. In New York City and beyond, there is no shortage of options, each bringing its own unique flavor and style. This article will take you through some of the best pizzerias in NYC for take-out, from Bleeker Street to Brooklyn, ensuring you find the perfect slice to satisfy your cravings.

Exploring the Best Pizzerias in NYC

New York City is a food lover's paradise, and its pizza scene is no exception. From the classic coal-fired style to innovative toppings, NYC pizzerias have it all. Here are the top three take-out options that are worth seeking out:

John’s of Bleeker

John’s of Bleeker is a Harlem staple that has been serving authentic Italian fare since 1989. Their hand-tossed pizza is known for being crispy on the outside and melty on the inside, making it perfect for take-out. The best way to enjoy a slice here is with their renowned Salame and Pepperoni combo, which features a balanced blend of savory and spicy meats on a thin, chewy crust. Although the restaurant doesn't offer dine-in, their take-out is a hit, and you can find them in the official website.

Grimaldi’s

Grimaldi’s, located in Brooklyn, is an institution in its own right. Known for its wood-fired pizza, the place has been serving up delicious pies since 2005. Grimaldi’s is famous for their Neapolitan style pizza, which is characterized by its spongy, charcoal-grilled texture. Their popular Sicilian Margherita pizza comes without peppers and with oregano, adding a touch of authentic Italian flavor. Take-out is just as good as dine-in, and customers often come from all over the city to relish in their famous slices. Grimaldi’s sits proudly at the corner of 14th Street and 2nd Avenue, and you can find more information on their official website.

Don Giovanni

For those with a taste for simplicity, Don Giovanni is the perfect choice. This tiny yet popular pizzeria in the Lower East Side is known for its simple, classic toppings and crispy bottom to withstand the heat of the oven. Don Giovanni takes pride in using only the finest ingredients, including fresh San Marzano tomatoes and mozzarella di bufala. Their Marinara pizza is a favorite, served with just olive oil and a touch of herbs. While they don't have dine-in service, their take-out options are sought out by many. To learn more about Don Giovanni, visit their official website.

The Brooklyn Scene

While these top three pizzerias are in NYC proper, Brooklyn is home to its own set of pizza legends. Here are the best places to get a slice in Brooklyn:

Di Fara

Di Fara, located in Brooklyn Heights, is a classic in the pizza world. This small, no-frills spot has been around since 1950, serving up street-style pizza slices to take out. The wait times can be extensive, but the reward is a slice of heaven. Be prepared to queue, but the classic Pepperoni and Clam slices are well worth the wait. Di Fara remains closed to dining in, so you'll need to come with an appetite or share with friends. Find out more about Di Fara on their official website.

Lucali

Over in Greenpoint, Lucali is a standout in the pizza scene. Known for their hand-tossed, coal-fired slices, Lucali offers a traditional Italian dining experience that you can take out with you. Their menu features a variety of toppings, but the Margherita and Innovation slices are particularly popular. Lucali also has a slice-only service at their multi-location spots, making it easier to get that perfect slice without waiting for a whole pie. For more information, visit their official website.

Add Some Variety to Your Take-Out Experience

For a slightly different take on pizza, you might want to explore Di Fara’s slice-only locations or Lucali’s Innovation slice, which often showcases unique and experimental toppings. The slice-only options are always a hit in these places, and the quick service means you won't have to wait long to start enjoying your meal.

Lastly, if you're in the mood for a thicker crust, Spumoni Gardens is a must-try. Their pizza is characterized by its layers and is a great choice if you're looking for something different from the classic New York style.

A Word on Take-Out Quality

One of the most important factors to consider when ordering pizza to take out is the quality. A well-kept oven and fresh ingredients are key, especially in a take-out setting. The best pizzerias in NYC and Brooklyn understand this and ensure that each slice is as good as it can be, even when picked up quickly.

Final Thoughts

No matter where you are in New York City or Brooklyn, there is always a pie that can satisfy your craving for pizza. Whether you prefer a traditional or experimental slice, these pizzerias can accommodate your tastes. While some places require a visit for the full experience, others are more than happy to serve you up a perfect slice to take away. Make sure to try these places if you're in the area, or order online if you're not. No matter the method, the taste of a freshly parmesan-grated slice out of the oven is worth the effort.

Note: Due to the dynamic nature of small businesses, it's always a good idea to check the official websites and social media channels for the latest updates and opening/closing times.