The Quest for the Best Bagels: A Guide to Top Baking Hubs
Bagels have a special place in the hearts of millions of people worldwide. Walking down the streets of New York City with a freshly made bagel is an experience that never fails to delight. This article takes a dive into some of the best places to indulge in this beloved treat.
The Best Bagel Picks in New York City
New York City is the home to some of the most famous bakeries specializing in bagels. Each of these bakeries has its unique twist on this bread staple. Here are our picks for the 15 best places to find the best bagels in the Big Apple:
1. Brooklyn Bagel Coffee Co. (286 8th Ave btwn W 24th and W 25th St, New York NY)
Brimming with character and flavor, Brooklyn Bagel Coffee Co. is known for its hand-rolled bagels that are baked in a wood-fired oven. Their morning specials and sandwiches are a must-try.
2. Absolute Bagels (2788 Broadway at W 108th St, New York NY)
Known for their perfect blend of traditional and modern flavors, Absolute Bagels promise a truly unique experience. Their bagels come in a variety of flavors, from the classic everything to more decadent options like flaxseed and gouda.
3. Tompkins Square Bagels (165 Avenue A btwn E 10th St and E 11th St, New York NY)
Located in the vibrant Tompkins Square area, this bakery is a go-to spot for bagel-lovers intrigued by innovation. While maintaining the classic taste, they serve bagels with unique and interesting twists.
4. Russ Daughters (179 E Houston St btwn Allen and Orchard St, New York NY)
Russ Daughters is a legendary establishment that has been around since 1914. Their bagels are legendary, and visitors can enjoy them with a side of smoked salmon or cream cheese for authenticity.
5. Best Bagel Coffee (225 W 35th St btwn 7th and 8th Ave, New York NY)
This trendy bagel shop offers a variety of bagels, from your traditional everything to more unique flavors. Their atmosphere is cozy and perfect for a quick morning run.
6. Ess-a-Bagel (831 3rd Ave btwn 50th and 51st St, New York NY)
A local favorite, Ess-a-Bagel crafts exquisitely prepared bagels that stand out with their robust flavors and fresh ingredients.
7. HH Midtown Bagels East (1551 2nd Ave at E 80th St, New York NY)
This charming bakery is a unique blend of old-world craftsmanship and modern ambiance. Their bagels are of the highest quality and are a perfect treat for the seasoned bagel enthusiast.
8. Sadelles (463 W Broadway btwn Prince and Houston St, New York NY)
Another favorite, Sadelles, is known for its delectable bagels and unique volcanic rock oven that adds a special crust to their baked goods.
9. Murrays Bagels (500 Avenue of the Americas btwn W 12th and W 13th St, New York NY)
With a broad portfolio of bagel flavors and a prominent reputation for generous slices, Murrays Bagels is a top choice for those seeking a classic New York City bagel experience.
10. Zuckers Bagels Smoked Fish (146 Chambers St btwn W. Broadway and Greenwich St, New York NY)
Famous for their nitrogen-infused smoked salmon, Zuckers Bagels Smoked Fish offers a fascinating blend of bagels, smoked fish, and a side of New York flair.
11. Bagelworks (1229 1st Ave btwn 66th and 67th St, New York NY)
Bagelworks is recognized for its meticulous preparation process, including boiling and then baking their bagels in a wood-burning oven, ensuring a perfect texture and flavor.
12. Leos Bagels (3 Hanover Sq at William St, New York NY)
Leos Bagels is known for its heirloom and heritage wheats used in their bagels, creating a unique flavor profile that sets them apart from more common options.
13. Davids Bagels (273 1st Ave at E 16th St, New York NY)
Famous for its bagel sandwiches, Davids Bagels offers an exceptional blend of traditional and gourmet flavors, making it a go-to spot for both breakfast and lunch.
14. Black Seed Bagels (176 1st Ave E. 11th St, New York NY)
Black Seed Bagels specializes in bagels with unique flavor profiles, including a wide variety of black seeds, creating a distinctive and rewarding taste experience.
15. St-Viateur Bagel (7457 Yonge St, Toronto, Ontario M2N 1M5, Canada)
Though not technically in New York, St-Viateur Bagel in Toronto is famous for its authentic Montreal-style bagels, and their popularity is a testament to the universal appeal of high-quality bagels.
How to Judge the Best Bagels
While the decision of which bagel is 'the best' can be subjective, several factors are consistent in determining a winner. Flavor, texture, and freshness are paramount, with many consumers also valuing consistency and authenticity.
The Myth: "Special" Water and the Quest for the Top Bagel
For decades, it has been debated whether the secret to the best bagel lies in the water used in its preparation. While water does play a crucial role in the texture and flavor, many factors contribute to a delicious bagel.
Bagel enthusiasts might argue that places like the Bagel Hole at Absolute Bagels and Tal Bagels, among others, might be contenders for the top spot. However, it's hard to pinpoint the absolute best, given the nuances of individual taste and preference.
Honorable Mentions
Other notable names in the bagel market include The Bagel Store, Kossars, Bagel Oasis, and Fairmont Bagels, which offer a range of traditional and gourmet options. For those who enjoy a spiritual connection, there are also special mentions of Turkey and Hong Kong bagels, which continue to capture the essence of authentic bagel making.
Whether you're in the heart of New York City or exploring the bustling streets of Montreal, the journey to finding the best bagel is an adventure worth taking. Each bite brings with it the promise of a delightful culinary experience.