The Falafel Tale: Israelis, Arabs, and the True Origin of this Middle Eastern Delicacy

Falafel, a beloved and ubiquitous ingredient in the Middle East, has a rich history that spans centuries and cultures. Many a debate has raged, and many a squared shoulders have met, over the true origin of this beloved delicacy. Israelis and Arabs claim, at various times, to have invented falafel. But in reality, the true story of falafel is far more intricate and fascinating than it might seem at first glance.

The History of Falafel

Legend has it that ashishim, a dish made from fried red lentils, is an early precursor to today's beloved falafel. The Jerusalem Talmud mentions this dish, indicating that ancient Israelites consumed a similar food.

However, Israelis do not claim to have invented falafel; they simply enjoy eating it. And so does a portion of the Arab population in Israel. For example, while many Israelis turn their noses up at matza in favor of hametz on Passover, some have a peculiar fondness for it, using it as a fun and unique ingredient.

The truth is, falafel has a much more complex and diverse history than a simple dispute over its origins might suggest. According to historical records, Egyptians, specifically the Coptic Christians, were responsible for inventing falafel in the 4th century. This was during a time when it was prepared as a food to be eaten during Lent.

Falafel: A Staple in Levantine Cuisine

In the medieval period, falafel gained significant popularity among the Coptic Christians of Egypt, as well as among Muslims and Jews. The dish rapidly spread due to trade and influence, becoming a staple food in Alexandria. Given Alexandria's position as Egypt's major port, it had extensive trade connections with other parts of the Levant, including Syria.

One of the key reasons for the spread of falafel was its plant-based nature. It became known as "pareve" — a term meaning kosher to eat with both meat and dairy dishes — in the Jewish community. This made it a popular dish for Egyptian and Syrian Jews during various religious festivals and traditions.

A Complex History and a Special Delicacy

By the 19th century, falafel had made its way to what is now Lebanon, where it became popular among Maronite Catholics.

But the story of falafel does not end there. Israelis, despite the fervor and passion of some of their detractors, are not seriously involved in the debate over its origin. It is a fact that never led to any significant disagreement. The Israelis were never a part of the falafel-making community before their modern settlement in historic Palestine.

The issue of who invented falafel is often used by some Israelis as a way to claim a historic and cultural heritage in the Middle East. It is similar to how some argue over the best football team in history, attempting to elevate the status of their team. These kinds of claims and counterclaims are typical Zionist methods and serve to create a narrative where Israelis can compete and be recognized for their contributions to Middle Eastern culture and history.

Ultimately, the true history of falafel is a testament to the rich and diverse cultural tapestry of the Middle East. It is a simple, yet special dish that has touched the lives of people from various backgrounds and beliefs. Whether it was the Copts in Egypt or the Jews in the Levant, the story of falafel is one of adaptation, innovation, and sharing among different cultures.

Key Takeaways: