The Decision Between Premade and Custom Paint: A Master Artist's Perspective

As an artist, the decision between using premade paints and grinding and dispersing pigments into one's desired medium is a complex one. With the vast array of high-quality pigments available today, many artists explore and experiment with both methods, sometimes finding a balance somewhere in between. Let's delve into the insights of an experienced artist who has navigated this decision and shares her approach.

Admiring the Old Masters and Modern Materials

I hold the Old Masters in high regard for their mastery of craftsmanship and technique. However, given the availability of advanced materials, I’m certain they would have embraced these whenever possible. While I could spend time grinding pigments and storing paint in animal bladders, I see no reason to indulge in such laborious practices. Instead, I opt for mixing new hues in any medium rather than using them straight from the tube. This approach allows for greater flexibility and creativity.

Embracing Versatility and Control

Versatility is my guiding principle as an artist. Sometimes the convenience of premade paints is essential, especially when working outdoors. At the studio, I’m more likely to go the extra mile, refining, degumming, washing, sun-drying, pre-polymerizing, and bleaching my own linseed oils. Then, I mix these with pigments in different proportions, achieving a wide range of hues and textures. This process grants me unparalleled control over the rheology and performance of my paint.

Time is a precious commodity. When I am outdoors, ready-made tubed paints are the go-to choice. But at the studio, I can push my boundaries, preparing my own oils and mixtures. No other oil paint dries as precisely as the one I create myself, without requiring toxic chemicals. The ability to choose different oils such as linseed, flaxseed, walnut, and poppyseed opens up a world of possibilities. I can fine-tune the viscosity and polymerization, ensuring the highest quality and performance of my custom paint.

Respecting Time and Expertise

There are many highly respected artists who meticulously grind their pigments and make their own colors. I deeply admire their dedication and skill. However, time is of the essence for me as an artist. I have much better things to do than spend hours grinding pigments and storing them in bladders. Instead, I opt for the best quality pre-prepared materials available, ensuring that I can focus on painting rather than on the technicalities of paint preparation.

While I do sometimes mix my own paints, the time constraints are often too demanding. Given my preference for versatility and control, I choose to purchase high-quality oil paints that offer a balance between convenience and quality. Mixing sometimes provides a deeper satisfaction and a sense of ownership over the final product, but time is a significant factor. As an artist, my primary focus is on the creative process and the end result, not the preparatory steps unless it greatly enhances the painting itself.

Ultimately, the decision between premade paints and custom mixtures comes down to a combination of necessity, personal preference, and the specific requirements of each project. Whether you’re an established artist or just starting out, understanding these options can help you make informed choices that enhance your artistic practice.