Introduction:

Around Northeast Ohio, it's rare to find someone who doesn't have an opinion on the best pizza by the slice. From traditional New York-style pies to Chicago-style squares, there are a variety of flavors and styles to choose from.

Historic Pizzas of Northeast Ohio

Yalas in Lorain:

Living in Lorain, Yalas became a favorite for many. They are known for serving the classic New York-style round pie. While decades have passed since I last enjoyed one, the nostalgic tanginess of their sauce and the satisfying grease from their pepperoni remain a point of reference. Their pies are a testament to the enduring appeal of traditional pizza-making techniques.

Traditional Pizzerias in Northeast Ohio

Pizza Oven in Canton:

These days, I reside in Canton, and Pizza Oven has won over my taste buds. The pizzas here are square and more akin to the Chicago-style variety. What sets Pizza Oven apart is their dedication to using fresh, homemade ingredients, including their sausage and dough. The result is a pie that truly stands out from the rest. My personal favorite? The mushroom sausage and banana peppers offerings, which always strike the perfect balance of flavors.

Pizza Culture in Northeast Ohio

The Transition from New York to Chicago Styles:

Northeast Ohio is uniquely situated between the pizza styles of New York and Chicago. This geographical advantage has led to a blend of both influences, with New York-style pizza being particularly popular. However, it's noteworthy that in most of Northeast Ohio, pizza is often part of a larger meal, making ordering just a slice somewhat unusual.

Other Popular Pizzerias in Cleveland

The Italian Influence:

While Cleveland boasts a vibrant and diverse food scene, pizza is often overshadowed by the city's exceptional restaurants. Areas like Tremont, Ohio City, and Gordon Square are known for their great dining options. Little Italy, in particular, is celebrated for its strong Italian-American heritage, but it's more common to find pizza served whole or as part of a full meal rather than by the slice.

Other Notable Pizzerias

Geracis and Other Favorites:

Geracis, nestled in Cleveland, is often praised for its authentic Italian-American cuisine. While they may not offer pizza by the slice, their quality dishes are a point of pride. Another popular spot is Mama Santas, which despite being a bit overrated to some, offers a delicious slice of history. Valentinos Pizza, on the other hand, is highly favored and definitely worth a visit.

Conclusion:

Northeast Ohio's pizza scene is diverse and rich, with each place contributing its unique flavor and style. Whether you're a die-hard fan of traditional New York-style pies or prefer the hearty Chicago kind, there's a slice (or pie) for everyone in Northeast Ohio. So next time you're in the area, don't hesitate to explore the vast array of pizza options available to you.