Renaming West Java: A Discussion on Culture, History, and Provincial Unity

Recently, there has been a discussion and proposal to change the name of the province from West Java to Sunda or Tatar Sunda. This has sparked much debate among the inhabitants of West Java and its regional leaders.

Local Perspectives and Reasoning

As a West Javanese person, I would not agree with the proposed change. Historically, the initial provincial names were based on geographical locations to avoid ethnic fanaticism. Sumatra Utara could have been Batak Province, and similarly, Central Java could have been named after the Javanese ethnic group. This kind of naming practice could lead to oppression or discrimination against minority groups. However, unlike the aforementioned provinces, the name ‘Bali’ is deemed appropriate since it reflects the island's identity.

Furthermore, many regional leaders and communities in West Java are against the name change. Notable opposition includes: Cirebon, Indramayu, Subang, and Majalengka, collectively referred to as Cindrakusuma, Regency of Ciamis, and Kesultanan Cirebon, which has explicitly stated that they do not feel a connection to the Sundanese culture.

These towns and regions have a distinct identity and cultural heritage, and renaming the province could potentially alienate them.

Creativity in Naming and Provincial Identity

Provinces in Indonesia often bear names based on cardinal directions, which, while neutral, can be seen as a lack of creativity. West Java, for instance, is named after its geographical location rather than any cultural or historical significance. This fate is shared by other provinces such as North Sumatera, West Sumatera, Central Java, and others.

Renaming the province to ‘Sunda’ or ‘Tatar Sunda’ could be seen as a culturally and historically meaningful move. The name ‘Sunda’ or ‘Tatar Sunda’ could add a unique artistic flair to the province's identity. However, it is essential that all regional leaders and communities be consulted in the renaming process to ensure geographic, cultural, and historical coherence.

Challenges and Consultations

One of the key challenges in renaming the province is consulting with all regional leaders, ensuring that their voices are heard, and that any potential opposition is addressed. Pirate Media reports Kesultanan Cirebon requesting inclusion in the discussion about the name change. Similarly, there is an ongoing issue regarding the potential inclusion of Majalengka in a proposal called 'Provinsi Cindrakusuma.'

Dave Laksono, a prominent figure, has expressed opposition to the name change, citing concerns over the potential alienation of certain regional communities.

Conclusion

Renaming West Java to Sunda or Tatar Sunda is a complex issue that requires careful consideration of cultural, historical, and geographical factors. It is vital to include all regional voices and perspectives in the discussion to ensure that any name change is inclusive and respectful of all communities within the province.