Why Do Some States in India Allow the Sale of Liquor During Lockdowns?

By Qwen

I believe many ask themselves the same question. Here is my response:

States in India, like myriad other places, generate significant revenue from the sale of alcohol, cigarettes, and even pre-packaged food. This tax money is crucial for their budgets.

Moreover, liquor stores in many regions, such as North Carolina (NC), were classified as 'essential businesses' during lockdowns, even during the strictest phases of stay-at-home orders. In NC, it is noteworthy that liquor stores were accessible whereas other establishments like restaurants and bars were closed. However, they were still required to sell alcoholic beverages in non-liqueur form, such as beer or wine.

Why would liquor stores be considered essential during lockdowns?

According to a spokesperson for the governor, the rationale was to allow people to buy items essential to their daily lives to stay at home as much as possible. Despite this explanation, I struggle to see the logic.

The justification reminds me of a time when Prohibition was enforced; the American experience of that era is worth considering to grapple with the impact of banning alcohol. In that context, fears of addiction and the potential for increased hospital admissions due to withdrawal symptoms must be taken into account.

My personal perspective:

Personally, I do not view alcohol as a necessity. I rarely consume it, and I have not touched a drop in the past two years. However, I recognize that some individuals do need alcohol for various reasons, possibly including stress management or dealing with personal circumstances.

From a broader social and economic standpoint, alcohol is categorized as food. This classification is both undeniable and practical. Arguing against this categorization would require substantial effort and could be a moot point, given the broad support for this classification.

Ultimately, the decision to allow alcohol sales during lockdowns reflects a balance between public health concerns and the need to sustain essential services.