Is a Triple Decker Sandwich Possible Without Bread?

When it comes to the quintessential quintuple decker sandwich, the question of whether one can be made without bread can be quite contentious. However, the answer truly depends on how strictly you define your culinary standards.

Traditionalists vs. Innovators

For those of us who are purists and slightly pedantic, like me, the answer is a resounding 'no.' A sandwich, or at least the classic understanding of it, requires bread as its base. This is not unlike saying you cannot make paella without rice or pasta without noodles. In my opinion, spaghettini is not pasta, and ‘noodled veggies’ do not count as pasta. Similarly, in my view, a sandwich without bread is not a sandwich.

Understanding the Definition of a Sandwich

However, if you are more open-minded and your interpretation of a sandwich is more flexible, there are other approaches you can consider. Beth Goldowitz, in her answer, suggests using creative elements such as woven bacon. Her idea of using bacon as a separator and substituting top and bottom bread layers with lettuce or jicama cuts, especially for smaller slider sandwiches, is intriguing. While it might lead to an exceptionally rich sandwich, it is an innovative solution that challenges traditional norms.

Alternative Bases for a Rich Sandwich

In her answer, Beth also mentions the possibility of using an easy mug bread made from coconut or almond flour, baking powder, and eggs. This could be an excellent gluten-free option for those who are sensitive to gluten but still wish to enjoy a sandwich. The process, involving a microwave for only about five minutes, is quite convenient and can serve as an excellent base for various fillings.

Exploring Other Non-Bread Bases

Furthermore, if you're looking for a more traditional non-bread base, you can consider mug bread, which is becoming increasingly popular. This type of bread can be made quickly with simple ingredients and can be sliced and toasted for use as a sandwich base. While I have yet to try a mug bread recipe, I have had several mug cakes that were surprisingly delicious. This method would allow for a sturdy sandwich without the traditional bread.

Blurring the Lines Between Dishes

It's important to note that sometimes, the naming conventions of culinary creations can be quite flexible. For instance, if you place pineapple and Canadian bacon on baked dough with tomato sauce and cheese, it is not technically pizza, regardless of what you call it. It can be called a 'Hawaiian flatbread' if that suits your taste better. Similarly, calling it a 'Hawaiian pizza' might satisfy your craving for the sweet and salty flavor profile, but it deviates from the traditional pizza definition.

The Wikipedia article on sandwiches provides a comprehensive breakdown of the variety of dishes that fall under the category of sandwiches. The common thread among them is the use of bread as a wrapper or base. A sandwich typically consists of various fillings like meats, cheeses, and vegetables placed between or on slices of bread, making this bread an essential component of the dish.

Conclusion

In conclusion, while a triple decker sandwich typically requires bread, exploring alternative bases such as paneer, tofu, or a hybrid like mug bread can offer new and exciting possibilities. The key is to stay creative while keeping in mind the fundamental purpose of a sandwich as a portable, filling, and versatile meal.

Reference to Beth Goldowitz's Answer

Beth Goldowitz, Beth Goldowitz, is known for her innovative culinary ideas, particularly when it comes to using bacon as a weaving element for a sandwich. Her creative approach offers a new perspective on traditional sandwich making. While it may result in a particularly rich and hearty sandwich, it can bring a new dimension to your culinary menu.