Is It Proper to Call Yourself Scotch-English?
When it comes to identifying one's heritage, there can be many shades of complexity and nuance. The question of whether it is proper to call yourself ‘Scotch-English’ is a telling example of how personal identity intersects with cultural and linguistic affiliations.
The Concept of Scotch-English
The term 'Scotch-English' does not exist in the traditional sense of a hyphenated nationality. Unlike 'Scots-Irish' or 'Irish-English,' the specific combination of 'Scotch-English' is not recognized linguistically or culturally. 'Scotch,' refers to a blended or malt liquor specifically from Scotland, not as a descriptor for individuals.
The concept often arises in discussions about cultural identities and mixed heritage. Some might attempt to create a portmanteau using their family background, but in reality, the term is not formal or widely used.
Cultural Affiliations and Nationality
Cultural affiliations and national identity are fluid and often depend on where one was born and raised, as well as the cultural and political context. Identification can be further complicated by DNA tests and genetic ancestry. While DNA can reveal a person's heritage, it does not always determine one's cultural or national identity.
For instance, in the case of the author who identified as a white Australian with ancestors from the UK, the decision to call oneself 'Aussie' or 'British' is more about where one feels a connection and where one currently resides. Legal citizenship, background, and personal preference all play a role in this complex identity.
Hyphenated Identities
Hyphenated identities, such as 'Scots-Irish' or 'Irish-American,' are more common and recognized. They represent a blend of cultures and often a form of cultural pride. For example, an individual who has Scottish and English heritage might identify as 'Scots-English' to honor both backgrounds.
However, if someone's primary identity is formed by their place of birth and upbringing, they might confidently call themselves by the nationality of their country of residence, such as 'English' or 'Australians.'
Personal Reflections and Cultural Pride
Personal reflections on these identities can also vary. Some individuals might feel a strong connection to both cultures and embrace both identities, even if they don't fit neatly into a commonly recognized category. This can be seen in the statement, 'One day I will understand hyphenated Americans but at this point in time I just don't get it.' Here, the individual is still exploring their own identity and the nuances of cultural pride.
Others, like the author who never used 'Scotch-English,' might feel that such a term is insecure or even 'pathetic.' This reflects the cultural sensitivity of self-identification and the importance of personal choice in defining one's heritage.
Ethnicity and DNA
Ethnicity is a complex combination of genetic, cultural, and social factors. DNA can reveal genetic ancestry, but it cannot fully determine one's ethnic identity. Ethnic identity is often more about how one chooses to identify oneself and the culture they align with, rather than just genetic makeup.
As one identity expert pointed out, 'Ethnicity isn′t about DNA. If one of your parents are Scottish and the other is English, you may have two ethnicities if you speak both languages—English and either Scots or Gaelic.' This highlights the importance of language and cultural practices in shaping identity.
In conclusion, the question of whether to call oneself 'Scotch-English' is a matter of personal choice and cultural affinity. It is essential to respect the individual's sense of identity and not impose a rigid or culturally insensitive label. Understanding and valuing diversity in cultural and national identities is key to fostering a more inclusive society.