Exploring the Best Pizza in Portland, Maine: Personal Favorites and Recommendations

Portland, Maine, is a city renowned for its unique flavors and exceptional dining experiences. Pizza, a beloved classic, plays a significant role in the culinary landscape. Whether you prefer a thin and crispy crust or a thick, soft one, there's a slice of heaven somewhere in Portland for every taste. Let's dive into the various options, from the trendy and gourmet to the classic and nostalgic.

Scanning the Scene: Personal Preferences and Local Delights

When it comes to pizza, one of the key considerations is the crust. Different structures offer different experiences, whether one craves the crispiness of a thin crust or the indulgence of a thick, soft one.

Otto’s

For those who appreciate a little refinement in their pizza, Otto’s is a standout. Known for its thin, creative crust with a variety of toppings, this place also boasts an impressive selection of draft beers. The crust is nothing short of exquisite, though the prices can be a bit steep. A single slice is a perfect choice if you're not ready to commit to an entire pie.

Slab

Slab, on the other hand, offers a very different experience. The restaurant’s signature is its thick and bready crust, which is noticeably flavorful, especially in their larger slice sizes. Outdoor seating during the summer months adds another layer of enjoyment. However, it might not be the first choice for purists accustomed to a thinner crust.

Flatbread

Flatbread is another recommendation, particularly appreciated in Portland’s Old Port and other locations in New England. The thin crust here is complemented by excellent toppings, satisfying pizza enthusiasts of varying tastes. This place offers a versatile menu that caters to a wide range of pizza lovers.

Delving Deeper: Traditional and Authentic Pizza Experiences

While explorations like Otto’s, Slab, and Flatbread offer unique experiences, some locals have a fondness for more traditional, pizza-centric establishments that align with their childhood memories or personal preferences.

Pizza Joint and Stavros Deli

For those who pine for the flavors of New Jersey, where the pizza is to die for, you might want to visit Pizza Joint on 448 Forest Ave. This place delivers a thin, crisp crust with a delightful red sauce and gooey cheese. It's a go-to spot for many looking for authentic Italian-American pizza.

Stavros Deli, also located on Forest Avenue, offers a similar experience. The establishment across the street and next door to Burger King, respectively, provides a nostalgic taste of the classics. While the air of Burgers and Fries might seem at odds, the pizza is anything but ordinary.

Pat’s Pizza

If you're inclined towards a thin crust pizza and don't mind a bit of entertainment on the side, Pat’s Pizza is a must-visit. This place often features live performances, adding an extra touch of dynamism to your dining experience. The pizzas are delicious, with great toppings and a very satisfying texture. A traditional pizza with tomato sauce and good cheese, just as it should be.

Maine Beer Company’s Pizza

For the ultimate pizza experience, a quick drive to Freeport may be worth it. The Maine Beer Company, with its companion wood-fired pizza business, serves a thin wheat crust that is simply delectable. These pizzas are known for their exceptional quality, making them a year-round favorite. The ambiance and the quality of the beer complement the pizza perfectly, providing a truly memorable dining experience.

Conclusion: Your Pizza Journey in Portland, Maine

Portland, Maine, offers a wide array of pizza options, from trendy and creative to authentic and classic. Each pizzeria has its unique charm and appeal, making it a destination worth exploring. Whether you're seeking a unique, artistic take on pizza or a slice of nostalgia, Portland has something for everyone. So, next time you're in town, venture out and taste the best pizza Portland has to offer!