Did Walder Frey Have a Grudge Against the Tullys?

House Frey is the vassal of the House Tully, who are the Lords Paramount of the Riverlands. This feudal relationship typically implies loyalty and service to their liege lord. However, the history between House Frey and the Tullys is complex and filled with betrayals and violence, raising questions about possible grudges or motives for revenge. This article explores the historical context and events that may have led to such tensions.

Feudal Relationships in Westeros

In the world of George R.R. Martin's A Song of Ice and Fire series, which also inspired the hit HBO series Game of Thrones, the relationship between vassal houses and their liege lords is crucial. A vassal house, like House Frey, pledges loyalty and service to a liege lord in exchange for land and protection. This relationship is based on ancient oaths and shared blood feuds that often span generations.

However, the Tully and Frey households have a complicated history that goes beyond the traditional responsibilities of vassals and their liege lords. The Freys' long-standing alliance with the Tullys is one of co-dependency rather than familial affection. While the Freys are obligated to serve the Tullys, the question remains: could they desire revenge against the Tullys?

The Tullys and House Frey

The House Tullys, known for their motto “All Men Must Die,” control the Riverlands and are fiercely patriarchal. The Freys, on the other hand, are described as a cunning and ever-so-slightly deranged house. The relationship between the two is complex, strained, and often marked by mutual distrust.

Historically, House Frey and House Tully have shared a marriage alliance through the blood of the Tully matriarch, Roslin. However, this alliance was not without its tensions. Roslin Frey, Walder Frey’s daughter, was largely overlooked by Robb Stark, the King in the North, after her father's death. This lack of attention from a key ally and marital partner could have contributed to feelings of neglect and resentment.

The Grudge and Possible Motives for Revenge

The stakes for any vassal betraying their liege lord can be extremely high. In Westeros, betraying a liege lord is not only a breach of trust but can lead to the downfall of the entire house. It is, therefore, highly unlikely for the Freys to want outright revenge against the Tullys. Their survival and continued prosperity in the region depend too heavily on their alliance, which is necessary for their continued control over a vast stretch of land.

Nonetheless, it is worth noting that Lord Walder Frey, known for his infamous betrayals, may have personal reasons for harboring grudges. After his daughter’s death, any sign of disrespect or neglect from Robb Stark could have fueled a vendetta. Additionally, the Freys have a reputation for cunning and opportunism. Given their history, it is within their character to exploit any perceived slights or betrayals to their advantage, even if it means not openly declaring war.

The Role of Personal Vendettas and Double Standards

The Tullys are portrayed as well-meaning and noble, which makes them more likely to be perceived as victims in any conflict. Lord Walder Frey, however, is a more complex figure. His past betrayals and double standards can be seen as a clear indication of his willingness to use any means necessary to achieve his goals.

Despite the supposed close relationship between the Freys and the Tullys, Lord Walder Frey's actions in storming Riverrun and leading to the deaths of many innocent lives in The Red Wedding demonstrate a disregard for honor and loyalty. This pattern of behavior is more in line with personal vendettas and the preservation of his own power, rather than a desire to avenge the Tullys.

Conclusion

While House Frey is bound by the feudal system to serve the House Tully of Riverrun, the complex and often strained relationship between the two households leaves room for personal grievances and grudges. The history of betrayal and deceit in Westeros makes it plausible that Lord Walder Frey could have harbored a grudge against the Tullys, but more likely, his actions were driven by his own ambitions and the need to protect his fortune and position.

Understanding the motivations of the Freys and Tullys in the context of their history and the rigid social structure of Westeros is crucial for any analysis of their interactions in the War of the Five Kings and beyond.