Comprehensive Comparison: Smith Wesson SW Shield Plus vs. SW Equalizer

Smith Wesson (SW) offers a robust lineup of handguns, catering to various preferences and needs. Two popular models in the 9mm chambering include the SW Shield Plus and the SW Equalizer. In this article, we will delve into a detailed comparison of these two models to help you make an informed decision.

Design and Aesthetics

The SW Equalizer stands out with its sleek, ergonomic design. When I briefly held one, it fitted my hand perfectly and had a quality feel to it. The Equalizer offers essential features such as a grip safety and a thumb safety, which I personally value. In contrast, the SW Shield Plus uses a trigger lever safety, which while functional, may not be as appealing to some shooters.

Disadvantages and Challenges

One notable disadvantage of hammer-fired semiautomatic handguns like the SW Equalizer is the potential for the hammer to catch on clothing or other objects. This issue is mitigated in the Equalizer, which has an internal hammer. However, this also changes the shooting experience, altering the feel and functionality of the firearm.

Practical Experience with SW Products

Even though I haven’t personally fired the SW Shield Plus, my wife, who owns a SW Shield and has degenerative joint issues, handles it with ease. Her experience highlights the accessibility and ease of use of the SW line, particularly with models like the Shield and Equalizer. My own experience with SW products, such as the MP9 and MP9C, further supports the overall reliability of the brand.

Personal Preference and Handgun Handling

While I don’t have extensive experience with the SW Equalizer, shooting 13 rounds through one has given me a good feel for its mechanics. The slide serrations on the Equalizer are more pronounced, providing a better grip, which can be a significant advantage for those with difficulty racking the slide. Additionally, the backstrap safety on the Equalizer is something I personally dislike, which reflects on the overall design.

Trigger Pull and Mechanism

I found the trigger pull of the SW Shield Plus to be more familiar, using the same striker-fired mechanism as other SW pistols. This consistency is comforting for shooters accustomed to similar mechanisms. The SW Equalizer, with its internal hammer, has a different feel, but the trigger pull was not unpleasant. The shorter reset was appreciated, making the shooting experience smoother.

Conclusion and Final Thoughts

Ultimately, whether the SW Equalizer or the SW Shield Plus is better depends on personal preference and specific needs. The Equalizer is easier to rack the slide, and its internal hammer system addresses the primary disadvantage of the traditional hammer-fired design. If ease of use and familiarity with specific mechanisms are important, the Shield Plus might be the better choice.

Given the limited experience I have with the Shield Plus, I strongly recommend trying both models at a gun range or using a rental for a more hands-on comparison. Only then can you make a well-informed decision based on your personal preferences and experiences.